While local Presbyterians continued to be members in the other churches in the 18th and 19th centuries, there were attempts at establishing a lasting congregation in the town of Beaufort. The first Session officially established First Presbyterian Church of Beaufort in 1912, and started sanctuary construction in 1928. In the spring of 1929, the congregation started worshipping in the new white clapboard-framed church in the colonial revival style with tall, arched windows of clear glass. In 1941, all appointments to the interior were complete and all debt cleared. The Beaufort Gazette then wrote, “This beautiful and artistic little church is a source of pride and gratification not only to the Presbyterians of Beaufort, but to the entire community.”
In the 1960’s, the church grew to more than 200 members, and the time was right to build a two-story educational building across North Street, as well as a Manse (which was sold in the late 1980’s).
Another cycle of church growth was marked in 1991, when Charleston-Atlantic Presbytery asked for 100 First Presbyterian Church members to become the founding families at Sea Island Presbyterian Church on Lady’s Island.
In May 2012, First Presbyterian Church of Beaufort celebrated its 100th Anniversary. To commemorate the centennial, a time capsule was built into the wall in the Education building, to be opened May 2037 and every 25 years thereafter.
Over the decades, the sanctuary and education building have undergone various renovations, but the original design has been retained and represents an important part of Beaufort’s church history.